Sourdough — A Series #2 Now let’s make some dough
by Cary and Patty ~ My Simply Sage
So now you have a starter. What do you do with it? You’ve spent a little time and effort getting your own vibrant starter going. It’s bubbling, rising and doing what a good starter is supposed to do. Now what?
Flour, water, starter and a little salt.
That’s all you’re going to need. Well…and a bowl.
First, Let’s Talk About Flour
There are a lot of different flours out there, and most of them will make bread. I’ve used all-purpose flour. Whole wheat flour. Rye flour. And a little bit of everything in between.
For my basic sourdough, though, I like a good bread flour, usually with a protein content somewhere around 12% or a little higher.
Why?
Because some of the proteins in flour combine with water and eventually form gluten. That gluten gives our dough strength and elasticity and helps it hold onto the gas our starter produces during fermentation.
In simple English:
It helps our bread rise and gives it structure.
Some flour makers put the protein percentage right on the package. If they don’t, you may be able to find it on their website. But please don’t turn this into another sourdough science project.
Buy a good bread flour and make some bread.
You can also mix flours. I sometimes replace part of my bread flour with whole wheat, rye or another flour when I want something different. I’ve never made my basic sourdough using only rye or whole wheat. That’s another adventure for another day.
Here’s My Basic Dough
For one loaf, I start with:
500 grams flour
325 grams water
100 grams active starter
10 grams salt
That’s it.
The 325 grams of water to 500 grams of flour gives us a nice starting point of about 65% hydration. You’ll see that word hydration a lot in sourdough recipes. Don’t let it scare you.
For now, it simply means how much water we’re using compared with the amount of flour.
If I want to add another type of flour, I might do this:
400 grams bread flour + 100 grams of another flour Whole wheat, rye—whatever I’m playing with.
I usually make two loaves at a time, so I simply double everything.
Do I Really Measure Everything?
When you’re starting out, I think you should.
A small kitchen scale makes this incredibly easy and gives you a good starting point while you’re learning what the dough should look and feel like. But I’ll tell you a secret.
I don’t split hairs anymore.
These days I measure my flour in a large measuring cup. Water in another measuring cup. Salt in my hand. And I pretty much know what 100 grams of starter looks like coming out of my jar. A little more starter isn’t going to ruin the bread. A little less usually just means things may take longer, depending on how active the starter is. But that comes with experience. For your first few loaves? Use the scale. Pretty soon you’ll begin to understand why I don’t worry about every gram anymore.
Let’s Make Some Dough
I put the water in the bowl first. I think it helps keep everything from sticking quite so badly to the sides of the bowl.
Then I add my starter and stir it into the water.
Now slowly mix in the flour. I use my spurtle for this. You can use a wooden spoon, your hands or whatever works for you.
Slowly mix everything together.
Some people do it the other way around. Flour first, then gradually add the water. Many people using that method mix with their hands and add the starter later.
Does one method make better bread? Who knows? I couldn’t tell you and I’ve done it both ways.
I put the water in first. It works for me.
At this point your dough is probably going to look pretty shaggy. That’s okay. In fact, that’s what we’re expecting.
DON’T PANIC AND ADD WATER!
This is something I learned the hard way. Your shaggy dough may look too dry. And the beginner’s immediate reaction is:
It needs more water! That was my ‘beginner’ reaction also.
BUT WAIT.
Unless you’re absolutely sure it needs more water, give it some time. Let it do its thing. The flour hasn’t absorbed all the water yet. If you keep adding water because the dough doesn’t immediately look right, pretty soon you can run the hydration way past where it should/needs to be. And then you’ve got… Goop.
You can usually rescue it by cautiously adding a little flour, but then you’re chasing the dough in the other direction. Water. Flour. More water. More flour.
We’ve turned four ingredients into a negotiation. 😂 It’s way easier to just wait.
When everything is almost mixed, I sprinkle my salt across the dough and work it in.
There’s lots of discussion about exactly when salt should be added and why. I’ve tried different ways. I’ve just never seen enough difference in my bread to worry about it. Add the salt whenever you like.
Everything is mixed, looking a little shaggy, now all you need to do is just cover the bowl and leave it alone for about an hour. I use a disposable shower cap over my bowl. Works great and helps maintain the moisture. While you’re now doing something else, the flour is absorbing the water. When you come back, that shaggy-looking mixture will already be starting to look and feel more like dough.
Now We Give It a Few Folds
Slightly wet the hand or hands you’re going to use. That does two things: it helps keep the dough from sticking to your hands, and it adds just a tiny bit of moisture to the mix. Reach underneath the dough, gently stretch part of it upward and fold it over itself. Turn the bowl and do it again.
How many times? Some instructions will give you an exact number.
I just do it until I like it.
Maybe twice. Maybe three times. This is where experience eventually takes over.
Let the dough rest another 30–40 minutes and do the same thing again.
Stretch up.
Fold over.
Turn the bowl.
Do it a few times.
Then give it another 30–40 minutes and repeat the process.
By now something interesting has happened.
That shaggy mess you started with is becoming real bread dough.
It should be smoother. It should stretch more easily. It shouldn’t be sticking quite as badly to the bowl or your hand. You’re learning something here that’s difficult to teach in a recipe. What good dough feels like. And the only real way to learn that is to make some dough.
Now Leave It Alone
Once I’m satisfied with the dough, I cover it and let fermentation do the work.
Why a Proofing Box—or My Microwave?
People have used proofing boxes for years to give dough a nice warm place to rise. They’re still commonly used today, especially in colder kitchens. Some folks routinely use their oven the same way with just the light on.
Here’s a Cary trick.
I use my microwave. The microwave is OFF.
I leave the door cracked open just enough to keep the interior light on. That little light creates a surprisingly nice place for my dough to rise.
And because this is My Simply Sage, we didn’t just assume it worked. We checked it. My microwave settled at about 78°F—right in the neighborhood commonly used for proofing bread.
Yours may be different, so stick a thermometer in there and check it.
And, NO… Don’t turn on the microwave with your bread dough inside. 😂
Why proofing boxes or my microwave.
A reliable temperature. Some moisture control—my shower cap helps with that, and some people even put a cup of warm water in the microwave.
And, maybe most important, consistency from one baking session to the next.
Kitchen temperatures change with the seasons. This gives the dough a more consistent place to work.
___________________________________________________________________________
Okay, now leave it alone and let that wonderful glob of dough grow. It might take four hours. It might take six. I’ve waited eight or nine hours.
Temperature matters. Your flour matters. Your starter matters. The amount of starter matters.
Lots of things affect how long this takes. That’s why I don’t want you staring at the clock.
Watch the dough.
I generally want mine to roughly double in size and look puffy and full of life.
Give the bowl a little jiggle. You’ll begin to see that this isn’t the heavy lump of flour and water you started with. Fermentation has been at work. Be patient.
Let the dough tell you when it’s ready.
How Do You Know When It’s Really Ready?
This may be the hardest part of sourdough to explain.
Eventually…
You just know.
I realize that’s not particularly helpful when you’re making your first loaf. But think about learning to hit a baseball. Somebody can explain where to put your feet, how to hold the bat and when to swing. Eventually, you have to hit the ball. It’s the same with tying your shoes, combing your hair or a hundred other things you’ve learned to do.
You learn by doing it.
Sourdough is no different. Watch a few good videos showing properly fermented dough. See how it looks. Watch how it moves and jiggles. See how somebody handles it. Now you know what you’re aiming for.
Then make some bread. Your first loaf will teach you something. So will your second. Pretty soon you’ll look at that bowl and say:
Yep. That’s ready.
____________________________________________________________________________
Time to Preshape
When the rise is finished, it’s time to get the dough out of the bowl.
I lightly flour my work surface, tip the bowl and let gravity help the dough slowly come out. You may have to encourage it a little. Now we’re going to preshape it.
This is another one of those techniques that’s much easier to understand when you actually see somebody do it. My technical description?
Wrestle it. 😂
Push the dough gently with one hand and a scraper (I use a small plastic one) while using the other hand to tuck the opposite side underneath. Rotate it and do it again. You’re gradually turning that blob into a ball while building some tension across its outer surface. There are plenty of good videos that demonstrate this much better than I can describe it. And after you’ve done it a few times…You’ll just do it.
Let your preshaped dough rest for about 20–30 minutes.
The Final Shape
Now we’re going to turn that ball into the shape of our final loaf. I stretch the dough out. Fold one corner in. Then the other. I work my way down the sides, folding them inward—almost like stitching the dough together.
Then I roll the whole thing up and give it a final shaping using that same push-and-tuck motion we used during the preshape. Now it looks like a loaf. And by the way. If your dough is spreading everywhere and really difficult to shape, it may be too wet. Don’t panic. You’re still going to get bread—it just may be a little flatter than you planned.
So what’s all this preshaping and shaping business about?
My way of looking at it is pretty simple.
The preshape starts building some tension into the loaf—a nice outer surface that helps the dough hold its shape.
The final shaping tightens and organizes everything a little more while we’re trying not to squash all the gas our starter has spent hours putting into the dough.
That fermentation, along with good gluten development and careful handling, is what eventually helps give that beautiful open sourdough crumb.
And by “careful,” I don’t mean you have to treat it like a baby. You’re just trying not to squash out all the gas our starter spent hours putting into it.
Shaped…Now Into the Banneton
Now the loaf goes into the banneton. I put mine in with the pretty, smooth side down—on the bottom of the banneton.
Why? Because tomorrow we’re going to turn it over, and that pretty side will become the top of our loaf. Cover it and put it into the refrigerator. Mine normally stays there about 10–12 hours overnight. And now…
Go do something else. You’ve done enough.
Was That Really So Much Work?
Reading all of this makes sourdough sound like an all-day project. Time-wise in hours, maybe?
Work-wise? Not really.
The actual time you’ve spent doing something with the dough is probably only about 30–40 minutes. If it’s taking you much longer than that, you’re working too hard.
Most of those hours were spent waiting while flour, water and several billion of our little friends did the work. And remember the whole process we’ve just gone through:
Put the ingredients together.
Give the flour time to absorb the water.
Give the dough a few folds while you’re wandering through the kitchen.
Let it ferment until it looks and feels ready. Shape it.
That’s it. It takes a little while to get the hang of it. So did tying your shoes. Be patient.
Make some dough. And don’t overthink it.
Next Time — Let’s Bake Some Bread
Our starter did its job. Our dough did its job. Our loaf is spending the night in the refrigerator.
Tomorrow morning, we’re going to bake some delicious bread.
